"Buckets catching leaks in the attic for a few months is not ideal but it's a lot better than any alternative that involves being on a roof during winter.
Believe me, I've been there."
An online community for people who love old houses.
-
Anita Rosenberger
- Female
- Fair Haven, MI
- United States
- Blog Posts
- Discussions (5)
- Events
- Groups
- Photos
- Photo Albums
- Videos
Anita Rosenberger's Discussions
season for roof replacement (complete tear off required)
10 Replies
Wondering if anyone can tell me whether a roof can be replaced in the winter? I'm in MI and the temps are below zero with windchill, plus we have about 7" of snow on the ground. I desperately need…Continue
Started this discussion. Last reply by John K. Dec 29, 2010.
Anita Rosenberger's Page
Latest Activity
John K. replied to Anita Rosenberger's discussion season for roof replacement (complete tear off required)Anita Rosenberger replied to Anita Rosenberger's discussion season for roof replacement (complete tear off required)"Thanks! All good points. We have pretty much decided to wait and hope that we can patch as we go once it warms up (tomorrow I think actually, should be about 39) and based on what you've said, I will check what the mfgr. of the…"
John K. replied to Anita Rosenberger's discussion season for roof replacement (complete tear off required)"I've done my share of roofs and I do not understand why anyone outside of an unemployed roofer would be saying it's ok to do.
Even the instructions on the shingles say to not apply under a certain temperature ( I think 40F ).…"
KenK replied to Anita Rosenberger's discussion season for roof replacement (complete tear off required)"I would feel that way as the last thing I would want is someone getting hurt. I hope you're able to find a safe way to button up any leaks during the harsh MI winters."
Anita Rosenberger replied to Anita Rosenberger's discussion season for roof replacement (complete tear off required)"agree, and the economy has been so bad, that is what I was wondering, if they just need the work so pretty much willing to do anything...but does concern me. I'm thinking maybe we had better wait. thanks"
Anita Rosenberger replied to Anita Rosenberger's discussion season for roof replacement (complete tear off required)"this is what I'm worried about....safety and quality of work. thanks"
KenK replied to Anita Rosenberger's discussion season for roof replacement (complete tear off required)"I agree with the safety issue. The economy is pretty bad, and winter is not an ideal time to put on a roof. Hence, I could see a contractor wanting to get a job. Any job. Just make sure they'll licensed and have workman's comp."
Dennis M. Crookshanks replied to Anita Rosenberger's discussion season for roof replacement (complete tear off required)"Yes, but it is not a good idea.
The crew doesn't really want to be there.
The shingles are cold and crack easily.
Nail guns, if used, regularly drive nails right through brittle shingles.
Ice and water shield does not stick well.
If you…"
Anita Rosenberger replied to Anita Rosenberger's discussion season for roof replacement (complete tear off required)"Thanks - I'm a bit worried about their safety too - heavy winds on high pitched roof. Just doesn't seem like a great idea but I can see what you are saying about the potential for rain damage during a warmer season."
Lair Tienter replied to Anita Rosenberger's discussion season for roof replacement (complete tear off required)"You should be fine with having a rood put on now. I agree it is not the ideal time and I bet your roofers would too. It is painful to be out in that cold for hours on end. I have had 2 neighbors, here in northeren Iowa where…"
Anita Rosenberger posted a discussionseason for roof replacement (complete tear off required)
Wondering if anyone can tell me whether a roof can be replaced in the winter? I'm in MI and the temps are below zero with windchill, plus we have about 7" of snow on the ground. I desperately need a roof, and the roofer(s) is/are telling me that it is fine to replace now, and in fact they would rather sweep off snow than deal with the leaking in the spring. But....I always thought you needed warmer temps for the glue or tar etc. This is not really an "old" house so I apologize if I should…See More
Profile Information
- Tell us about yourself:
- We live in a rural area on 26.5 acres which we purchased so we could run our dogs on our property. (sleddogs)
- Tell us about your old-house experiences and dreams:
- Our house was built in 1989 so not really "old" however it was built CHEAPLY....everything is falling apart, and everything was done so poorly to begin with. We've been replacing small things up until now, but now we have some major systems which need to be replaced and we are trying to figure out best way to go given the housing market (resale) and current economic conditions.
Comment Wall
- No comments yet!
© 2013 Created by Community Host.
Old Houses | Restoration Products | Report an Issue | Terms of Service
